Scottish Crime Writer Calls for Licensing Model to Protect Creatives from AI ‘Theft’
Borders-based novelist Ed James urges government action as AI firms use authors’ work without consent
A bestselling Scottish crime author has launched a call for urgent action to protect writers and other creatives from what he describes as the “unauthorised harvesting” of their work by global AI companies.
Ed James, the Borders-based author behind the popular DCI Rob Marshall series, discovered recently that his entire back catalogue had been used without permission to train a large AI model developed by a major tech corporation.
Now, the former IT consultant turned full-time writer is proposing a new “incorporation licensing model” that would require AI developers to pay to access copyrighted creative works — and compensate artists when those works contribute to AI-generated output.
“These companies are using the best available creative data to train their systems, but they’re not paying for it,” said James. “If they want quality input, they should be paying creators for it — just as they pay for chips and energy to run the models.”
James’ intervention comes as concerns continue to grow within the creative industries over how artificial intelligence is reshaping everything from publishing to music. In February, over 1,000 musicians — including Annie Lennox and Damon Albarn — released a silent protest album in response to their work being mined for AI training.
While James acknowledges the potential value of AI, even using it himself for research purposes, he says the current landscape is “skewed too heavily” in favour of tech giants that profit massively from user-generated content and creative work, often without permission.
“It’s not that technology is evil,” he said. “The problem lies in unchecked corporate power and the lack of consent from creators whose work is being ingested into these models.”
He’s now calling on the UK Government to mandate that companies:
-
Disclose which works have been used to train their AI systems;
-
Compensate creators retroactively where applicable;
-
Offer a licensing scheme for future training purposes;
-
And provide opt-out rights for those who do not wish their work to be used.
Furthermore, James believes authors who participate should be eligible for royalty payments whenever AI-generated content draws meaningfully on their material.
The issue hits close to home for James, who was shocked to discover how up-to-date the training datasets had become — including his most recent releases: ‘His Path of Darkness’ (September 2023) and ‘False Dawn’ (November 2023).
“The tech firms have moved faster than we thought,” he said. “We need to catch up quickly and demand transparency and fair treatment for creators.”
James’s latest book, ‘Fear of Any Kind’, set in the Scottish Borders town of Hawick, opens with the grim discovery of a murdered teenager’s body. The novel, like his others, is now available in Kindle, Audio, and Print formats.
📘 Buy the book here: https://geni.us/EJM07LP